From August 9 to 11, Disney held a convention in Anaheim, California. The event brought together all of the different Disney studios to announce upcoming projects.
The convention featured announcements of live-action adaptations for “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs” and “Lilo & Stitch.” These films join the growing list of Disney’s live-action remakes, now totaling 20.
On September 11, students were asked to fill out a survey to share their opinions on on the two upcoming live-action projects, as well as past and rumored future projects.
Many students who were surveyed believed them to be unnecessary. While some do enjoy the adaptations, others view them as cash grabs that take away from the original films.
“They were made as animations for a reason, to try and grasp the same energy from live action just isn’t the same,” Lizzie Ogles said.
In the survey, students also shared their favorite and least favorite live-action Disney movies. While answers varied, most favored “Cinderella” (2015) for its emotional depth and disapproved of “The Lion King” (2019) mainly because it was made entirely with CGI and should not technically be classified as a live-action movie.
Although many Disney movies have been adapted, some original films remain untouched. Surveyed students listed movies they wish would be left alone, including “Treasure Planet,” “Brave,” “Toy Story,” “Tangled” and “Moana.”
Unfortunately, “Tangled” and “Moana” might not remain untouched for long. Unconfirmed rumors suggest live-action adaptations are in the works for these films.
Students shared their opinions on this. Some loved the idea while others were displeased, and thought it was not the best idea.
Instead of more live-action remakes, students who took the survey suggested that Disney should focus on creating original content, whether animated or live action. Many students specifically asked for new animated movies, particularly in the 2D animation style that has not been seen in years.
“Look at any of the live-action movies coming out recently, they are not profitable,” Eli Hamilton said. “They are not stylized and they add nothing to the original films.”
Maybe it’s time for Disney to rethink their approach on their content.
